The Best Coffee Creamer Reviews and Buyer’s Guide

For coffee lovers who want their coffee anything other than black, there are myriad options to play with — milk, cream, sugar, chocolate, spices, flavored syrups, even booze — and the possibilities are endless.

But the most basic of options apart from milk is the creamer, traditionally used as a dairy-free alternative to milk for those who can’t take lactose. But mostly, people use them on their coffee because they’re convenient, as they usually come in single-serve packets or cups, and because a lot of them these days come in different flavors, from the super basic vanilla and caramel, to the more exotic amaretto and pumpkin spice.

And thanks to its unique flavors and convenience, creamers are all the rage. Unfortunately, they are not always healthy. And that is because some creamers have high sugar, calories, and fat levels. So we did some research and prepared the following review of some of the best coffee creamers in the market.

The Best Coffee Creamers Are

1. Coffee-Mate Powder Original — Best Overall

You can’t beat the classic. Nestle is a renowned food company that has produced some of the best products in the market, and Coffee-Mate is no exception. This creamer is dairy-free, gluten-free, and lactose-free. And if you prefer powder over liquid creamers, then this product is perfect for you. This cholesterol-free creamer is ideal for folks who are on a strict diet or who love monitoring what you consume.

Coffee-mate powder has been around for a very long time, and it has grown in popularity, thanks to its unique taste and healthy ingredients. It is a delicious creamer that will transform the black coffee you like into a unique beverage you will love. Plus, you can create your favorite cup by adding and stirring the ideal amount of creamer to create a flavor that suits you perfectly.

You can take as much creamer as you want every day without worrying about adding more weight. This creamer can also be added to a wide range of recipes to create a unique flavor that everyone will love. 

Verdict: It's a classic for a reason. And the fact that Coffee-mate original is cholesterol-free means that it's ideal for people on a low-carb diet.

Overall rating: 4.8 out of 5

View on Amazon →

2. Land O Lakes Mini Moos Creamer Half & Half Cups

This creamer is the first single-serve product on our list that comes with 192 servings. Land O Lake creamer is quite popular in diners and gas stations worldwide thanks to its size. This classic creamer delivers a creamy and rich taste on the go. Made from cream and milk, this creamer introduces a touch of indulgence to your coffee.

This single-serve creamer is delicious and portioned just right, with each serving weighing about 2 grams. And thanks to its popularity, when coffee lovers are asked how much cream they need, this creamer is what the questions are based on. It provides a smooth, silky, and creamy beverage without being a lot for most coffee lovers.

This beverage is quite easy to prepare; all you have to do is pour it into your coffee and enjoy a smooth cup of Joe. But since it's milk-based, this product expires faster than most creamers in the market. 

Verdict: as a classic creamer that has been in the market for a very long time, this product won't disappoint. But you should be ready to use them as soon as they’re opened since they expire quickly.

Overall rating: 4.7 out of 5

View on Amazon →

3. N'Joy Non-Dairy Coffee Creamer

N'Joy has been manufacturing excellent food products for more than three decades, and this creamer is no exception. This creamer is quite common in convenience stores, hospitality, office break rooms, and homes. This product is a unique, straightforward creamer for anyone who wants to doctor their coffee. N'Joy creamer is a perfect substitute for half-and-half and milk. Plus, it contains no trans-fat, sodium, or cholesterol.

N'Joy creamer is neither too creamy nor too sweet. This product creates great caffeine beverages that are perfect and at an affordable price. But, this product is packed in a wide range of packaging. So if you order one, it might not look like the one found in most online shops.

Verdict: N'Joy creamer is a great product that can change your coffee's flavor on a budget. Plus, it's neither creamy nor sweet; therefore, you might need to add some sugar or a sweetener.

Overall rating: 4.6 out of 5

View on Amazon →

4. International Delight French Vanilla Coffee Creamer

Another gas station favorite that has been giving folks a creamy cup of joe for years is this International Delight classic. Even though it's not as common as Mini Moos, it is still a great addition to your coffee whether you're in the office, on the go, or at home. This unique creamer can transform your black coffee into a world filled with flavors. It is a coffee lover's dream with 288 servings that are both lactose and gluten-free. Therefore, you will always have more than enough to share with your co-workers, family members, and friends.

This creamer is filled with French vanilla flavor, and it requires no refrigeration. Every single serving will transform even your generic office pantry abomination into an exquisite treat rich in vanilla. 

Verdict: This is a perfect creamer that can fit in your purse, so you can have it everywhere you go. And its unique formula will guarantee you a flavor-filled beverage that you will enjoy.

Overall rating: 4.5 out of 5

View on Amazon →

5. Nestle Coffee-Mate Liquid Creamer

This creamer will please both coffee lovers and Snickers lovers! The chocolatey creamer is bursting with the flavors of nougat, caramel, and peanuts that the Snickers bar is known for that you didn’t realize you wanted in your coffee. Packed in a 1.5-liter concentrate pump bottle, this creamer is convenient and quite easy to use. Its unique packaging leaves no mess, reduces wastage, and is simple to clean. It has a reliable system that is tamper-proof and hard to remove once installed.

This creamer can retain its flavor for almost nine months and doesn't need to be refrigerated. And the good thing about it is that it has zero gluten, cholesterol, and lactose. Plus, a single pump is enough for a cup of coffee, and an entire bottle can provide flavor 300 servings. This creamer has a 30-day shelf life once opened.

Verdict: This creamer comes with a tamper-proof pump that reduces wastage and is easy to clean. Therefore, you will enjoy every single drop of this creamer for 30 days. And the fact that it's lactose and cholesterol-free makes it ideal for individuals who watch what they eat.

Overall rating: 4.2 out of 5

View on Amazon →

6. Primal Kitchen Collagen Fuel Protein MIX, Coconut Vanilla Creamer

Besides giving you the needed caffeine kick in the morning, wouldn’t it be awesome if your cup of joe could do more for your body — like make your skin and hair look better? So if your favorite beverage doesn't give you longer hair and improve your skin, then it's time you upgrade to this creamer. This creamer contains type-1 and 3 collagen peptides that help improve the health of your nails, skin, and hair.

This creamer has no artificial ingredients, preservatives, or fillers. So, it can offer a great taste without adversely affecting your health. It’s keto-friendly too and contains no soy, whey, dairy, or refined sugar. Plus, it's quite easy to use; all you have to do is mix it with liquid and stir to create a delicious coffee. Its powder packets make it a great option for people looking for a to-go beverage. Made from coconut milk powder and vanilla extract, this creamer will enhance the creamy flavor of your cuppa java. However, some coffee lovers have complained that it leaves a slimy gelatinous layer at the base of the cup.

Verdict: thanks to the bovine collagen peptides, this creamer can enhance the health of your nails, hair, and skin.

Overall rating: 4.5 out of 5

View on Amazon →

7. Nestle Coffee-Mate Hazelnut Coffee Creamer

This unique creamer will add a velvety rich hazelnut flavor to your beverage. Its unique bottle reduces spills and wastage, and it can provide 300 servings per bottle. It’s perfect for use in a self-service coffee station.

This hazelnut creamer is thicker than most liquid formats, and it has a 30-day shelf-life after breaking the seal. The fact that it's non-dairy means that it doesn't need refrigeration to remain fresh for a very long time. So go ahead and bring some hazelnut goodness to your kitchen or workplace!

Verdict: This hazelnut flavored creamer is cholesterol-free, so you will never have to worry about it affecting your weight loss plan.

Overall rating: 4.6 out of 5

View on Amazon →

8. Nutpods Cotton Candy Unsweetened Dairy-Free Creamer

Everyone who enjoyed cotton candy while growing up will surely love this flavorful creamer in their coffee. After all, it does taste like a childhood treat but without actual sweetener or sugar. This product is a smooth creamer that is prepared from coconuts and almonds. Plus, each serving contains zero sugar and is low-calorie. And the fact that it has no dairy, carrageenan, and soy means that it's safe for everyone, even the ones on a strict diet.

The cotton candy creamer has a long shelf life. You can store it in the pantry for a while. This cotton creamer is keto and paleo-friendly, gluten-free, OU kosher, gluten-free, and certified vegan. Unfortunately, some Nutpods' product lovers don't like this flavor.

Verdict: Nutpods cotton candy creamer is a unique flavor that will bring back all your childhood memories. It has no dairy; therefore, it's ideal for vegans.

Overall rating: 4.3 out of 5

View on Amazon →

9. Rapid Fire Ketogenic Creamer With MCT Oil

Would you like to lose weight while still enjoying your morning cup of beverage? Well, now you can, thanks to the high performance of the Rapid fire ketogenic creamer. This creamer is a keto-friendly product that supports metabolism and energy. Therefore, all coffee lovers on the keto diet can try this creamer. This easy-to-mix powdered creamer is made from Himalayan salt, coconut, and MCT oil.

The MCT oil is a human-made fat that is ideal for individuals who can't tolerate other types of fat. On the other hand, Himalayan salt helps reduce the bitterness of coffee. The butter from grass-fed cows contains levels of vitamin K and omega-3 fatty acids. 

It can help you stick to your low-carb diet and burn calories at the same time. Each serving can leave you feeling satisfied and help you lose weight. This creamer enhances healthy digestion, supports physical performance, and suppresses your appetite. This product can even boost your brainpower. But some coffee lovers have complained that it leaves some lumps at the base of the cup.

Verdict: Rapidfire ketogenic creamer is a great product that does more than just improve your drink. This creamer can also improve your health while helping you burn some extra calories. And the fact that it can boost your energy levels is a bonus.

Overall rating: 4.0 out of 5

View on Amazon →

Factors to Consider When Buying a Coffee Creamer

Coffee creamers are light creams that are used to add some flavor to a cup of Joe. Creamer can be a great option for coffee lovers who don't like taking their favorite beverage black. Fortunately, there are numerous creamers, both non-dairy and dairy, that can take your morning drink to another level.

Therefore, finding the right option can be quite tricky especially if you have any dietary restrictions. So here are some of the key factors you must consider when purchasing a coffee creamer.

Your Monthly Consumption

Determine how much coffee your entire household consumes per month and how many folks use creamers. So you can use the previous month’s consumption rate to determine the amount of creamer you will need. Fortunately, numerous studies have confirmed that, on average, coffee lovers drink more than 3 cups per day. And out of the three, only a third of their daily consumption will be black coffee.

Therefore, you can subtract the amount of black coffee consumed per day to get the right amount. Another factor that will help you determine the amount of creamer to purchase is your storage space. If you have no more space in your refrigerator, then you should stay away from liquid creamers that need refrigeration.

Liquid or Powder Coffee Creamer

Coffee creamers are available in either liquid or powdered form, and what you select is based on your preference. But the liquid creamers taste better than the powdered ones. On the other hand, powdered creamers have a longer shelf life and are quite convenient to carry around when they come in single-serve packets. So if you're looking for a creamer that won't spoil for a very long time, even after breaking the seal, you should go for a powdered product.

Liquid creamers tend to mix instantly with coffee, while the powdered ones may get clumpy when mixed with hot coffee. So if you dislike the idea of finding lumps at the base of your cup, you should go for a liquid creamer.

The Ingredients

Most products use additives and preservatives to increase the shelf lives of their products. So if you are an allergy sufferer, you should look and the list of ingredients and find out if it has anything that can affect you. Some creamers contain numerous unwanted ingredients like vegetable oil and hydrogenated corn syrup. If you're mindful of what you consume, you should select a creamer that is non-GMO. This means that the product will be safe for you and your entire family.

Dietary Preference

If you are on a strict diet, then you should keep it in mind when purchasing a creamer, and make sure to read the label. After all, there are numerous options in the market for lactose intolerant and vegans. So you can get a creamer that is keto or kosher friendly.

The Expiry Date

If you're buying a huge package of creamer, you must consider its shelf life. So make sure you look at the expiry date before buying your favorite creamer. Getting a huge package of creamer with a long shelf life will ensure that you always have some creamer around the house.

Added Sweetness or Flavor

If unsweetened coffee is too bitter for you, then you can get a creamer with sugar. Other products come with a wide range of flavors that can elevate your hot beverage. Some of the most popular flavors that you can try are peppermint mocha, coconut, chocolate, and hazelnut.

Final Thoughts

With numerous options available, we understand how overwhelming it can be to choose the best coffee creamer. We prepared this guide to help narrow your search for a delicious creamer for your coffee. 

The creamer that you absolutely can’t go wrong with is the Coffee-Mate Original. This classic non-dairy creamer is versatile and can be used as a foundation for concocting a lot of different coffee creations. Sure it may seem plain but you really can play with it and create some wild recipes. It has a very long shelf life and is ideal for people on strict diets.